Bathtub Or Shower: Deciding Between Two Great Options

Bathrooms are a space in the house where people spend a lot of time so it is important to make sure that you put some thought into what kind of features you want. In this post, we will explore bathtub or shower remodeling decisions and how they impact your home’s value. There are several things to consider before making an investment in either one of them, but we’ll help you along the way.

The Pros and Cons of Bathtubs

When it comes to bathtubs, there are a few pros that stand out. First, bathtubs provide a sense of luxury and relaxation. If you’re looking for a way to wind down after a long day, a bathtub can be the perfect solution. They can also be great for soaking tired muscles or easing joint pain.

Another pro of bathtubs is that they can be used as a means of relaxation and escape. If you have a stressful job or a lot of responsibilities, taking some time out for yourself in the bathtub can be really beneficial. Bathtubs can also add value to your home – many buyers are looking for this feature.

There are a few cons to bathtubs as well. First, they can be difficult and dangerous to get in and out of for some people. This is especially true if you have any type of mobility impairment. They can also take up a lot of space – something that might be an issue if your bathroom is small. Finally, bathtubs can be expensive to install and maintain.

White tub in a bathroom with a double vanity that resembles wood grain

The Pros and Cons of Showers

When it comes to showers, there are several pros that stand out. First, they are much easier and safer to get in and out of than bathtubs. This is especially true if you have any mobility restrictions. Showers are also much more space-efficient than bathtubs, which may be an issue if your bathroom is small. 

According to a study, children under five years old account for almost 30 percent of the 110,000 annual bathtub and shower-related accidents.

Another pro of showers is that they can help to keep the water from heating up as quickly as bathwater does – a huge energy saver! Finally, new shower options like walk-in bathtubs can be a great way to make the bathroom more accessible.

There are some cons of showers as well. First, they don’t provide that same level of luxury and relaxation as bathtubs do – unless you have an amazing shower head! They also may not add value to your home as bathtub upgrades can.

A glass walk-in shower with modern dark cabinets

Bathtub and Shower Options For Your Home

What are the best shower options? Which style is right for you, tub showers or walk-in showers? Explore bathtubs and see if there’s room to add an extra fixture that becomes a bathtub and shower.

Walk-In Bathtubs

If you have difficulty getting in and out of a bathtub, or if you just don’t want to risk slipping on the tile while taking a bath, walk-in bathtubs are a great option. They come with grab bars and non-slip surfaces to make bath time safer and more comfortable.

Freestanding Bathtubs

A freestanding tub is a great idea for those who have the room in their bathroom, but they can be difficult to install for do it yourselfers. They’re also not as easy to clean because bathwater tends to spill out onto the floor when you’re getting out. But they’re definitely a focal point and can go beyond the standard tub. Like most tubs, they can prove to be a disadvantage when it comes to water consumption, but if your home has the square footage for it, it can do wonders for yourself and all bathrooms in general.

Soaking Bathtubs

Soaking bathtubs are deep and usually come with a reclining backrest, making them perfect for those who want to relax and enjoy a bubble bath from time to time. They often have jets that can massage your body while you soak and heal your sore muscles. They’re perfect for small children and they’re favored over the traditional tub. You will have the best bathing experience and homebuyers are always excited about this bath addition.

Clawfoot Tubs

Clawfoot bathtubs are perfect for homes with Victorian-style architecture. They’re very deep and usually have ornate feet that add a touch of class to your bathroom. At least one tub can increase your home’s value and be an attraction for potential buyers. It can prove to be the perfect choice
Now that we’ve sorted through tub options, let’s see what type of showers can fit into your home.
Both bathtub or shower in a white bathroom

Traditional Shower

A traditional shower involves a bathtub or shower stalls that can be filled with water which is then drained away through a plug hole once the bather has finished. Many people find showers more convenient as they can be used without filling up the bathtub, and they are also easier to clean.

Walk-In Shower

Walk-in showers are a popular bathtub replacement option, especially for senior citizens or people who have trouble with mobility. They provide easy access to the shower without having to climb over a bathtub. They can also be more spacious than standard bathtubs. Walk-in showers usually have a seat, a handheld showerhead, and multiple showerheads.

Steam Shower

Steam showers are a luxurious addition to your average bathroom that can come with a variety of health benefits. When you step into a steam shower, the hot water causes the air to turn into vapor, creating a relaxing and therapeutic environment. They can help improve your respiratory health, help you lose weight, and even improve your skin health. They’re also perfect for relieving stress and muscle tension. If you’re looking for a way to upgrade your bathroom and enjoy some added health benefits, a steam shower may be the perfect option for you.

Shower Tub Combo

These bathtubs have a separate shower head, making it easier to get in and out of the tub without slipping on wet tile or having to reach over water from the bath. They’re also usually more attractive than traditional bathtubs because they don’t take up as much space.

Cost Of A Bathtub Shower Combo

If your upgrade from just a bathtub to a shower or tub-shower combo will be worth the investment. The bathtub replacement alternative is an investment that adds to the value of your home, especially if you’re planning on selling it soon. The average cost for a bathtub-shower combo with standard features is around $12,000-$14,500 installed (not including installation costs). It may be worth keeping in mind though that bathtubs are much cheaper than bathtub-shower combos.

The average bathtub with a faucet and showerhead is between $800-$1000, while a standard bathtub-shower combo falls around $1200-$1400 (installed). Also, walk-in tubs’ average price range is $1500 to over $6000.

Which one should you choose for your bathroom remodel project? It really depends on your specific needs and wants. If you are looking to replace an old bathtub, a walk-in shower might be the best option. If you want to upgrade from just a bathtub, then a tub-shower combo is probably the way to go.

No matter what you choose, make sure to get a few estimates from contractors before you start your project. This will help ensure that you get the best possible deal and avoid any surprises.

A modern bathroom with a simple vanity and a tub

Which Option Is Right for You

Are you in the market for a bathroom remodel? Whether you’re looking to replace your bathtub or install a new shower, there are a few things you need to consider before getting started. Here are a few tips to help you make the right decision for your home.

Determine Your Needs

Before you do anything, take some time to determine what kind of features you want in your new bathroom. Do you want a bathtub or a shower? Is space an issue? What about accessibility? Make a list of your needs and wants so you have a clear idea of what you’re looking for.

Consult With Professionals

It’s always best to consult with professionals when it comes to such an important purchase. Not only can they help you determine what features will work best for your home, but bathtub and shower remodeling contractors can also provide estimates on the cost of replacing bathtubs or installing new showers in your bathroom.


Choosing to remodel your master bathroom can be a big decision. It’s important to make sure you think about the features that will work best for you and what kind of investment is right for your budget before jumping headfirst into any one project or renovation idea. We want this post to help guide you through some of those decisions, so we’ll explore bathtub or shower remodeling options and how they impact home value as well as provide our top tips on finding the perfect contractor at every stage of the process from planning all the way up until after it’s done. In short, if you’re looking for an honest opinion on which option might be better suited for your needs, call us today! Our team would love to help you out with whatever you need.
A white tub in a bathroom with black floor tiles and a white toilet