Pros And Cons Of Adding A Kitchen Island In Your New Space

Many homeowners view a kitchen island as must-have feature for functionality and style. However, like any home improvement, it comes with both advantages and drawbacks.

This article provides an in-depth analysis of the pros and cons of installing a kitchen island, helping you make an informed decision. Ready to dive in?

Pros of Adding a Kitchen Island

Let’s first look at the pros of kitchen islands.

Kitchen remodeling Overland Park, Johnson County

Additional countertop and cooking space

Adding a kitchen island immediately increases your countertop space. Whether you’re preparing elaborate holiday meals or just making weeknight dinners, more counter space means less clutter and more efficiency.

With an added kitchen island, you turn your counters into versatile workspaces that accommodate multiple culinary activities at once!

Extra storage space

Kitchen islands offer the benefit of extra storage, providing solutions for households where cabinet and drawer space is at a premium. They come equipped with cupboards and shelves hidden beneath their countertops, perfect for hiding away pots, pans, or your collection of exotic spices. Adding a kitchen island to your layout brings in an element of more functionality to the area while ensuring that less space is taken up by freestanding cabinets or shelving units. This upgrade will not only make your kitchen tidier but also add convenience to using it on a daily basis.

Potential for extra seating

A kitchen island extends your seating options in a snap. It offers homeowners more comfort, with the ability to double as a breakfast bar or casual dining area. No need for a separate dining table taking up valuable space.

Pull up some chairs or stools to the island and you have an instant dining option. The extra seating also promotes family time and can even enhance entertainment opportunities when hosting guests, providing ample room for everyone. Movable islands are also a thing you can look into!

Improved space optimization in larger kitchens

Adding a kitchen island can greatly improve the space optimization in larger kitchens. With more room to work and move around, you’ll have better functionality and efficiency when preparing meals or hosting gatherings.

Plus, having an island creates a focal point in your kitchen, providing definition and balance to the overall design of the space.

Enhanced definition of space in open-concept homes

Adding a kitchen island can enhance the definition of space in open-concept homes. By strategically placing an island in the center of an open floor plan, it creates a natural division between the kitchen and other living areas such as the dining room or living room.

This not only adds visual appeal but also helps to establish separate zones within the larger space, giving each area its own purpose and functionality. Additionally, a kitchen island can serve as a focal point, drawing attention to the heart of your home and making it feel more inviting and well-designed.

Increased property and resale value

Adding a kitchen island can significantly increase the property value of your home. This is especially beneficial if you plan to sell your house in the future. Potential buyers are often attracted to homes with modern, well-designed kitchens, and a stylish and functional kitchen island can be a major selling point.

By investing in this upgrade, you are making your home more attractive to buyers, increasing its overall value, and potentially achieving a higher resale price when the time comes.

Coordinated kitchen decor

When it comes to designing your kitchen, having coordinated decor can make a big impact. By adding a kitchen island that matches the style and color scheme of your cabinets and countertops, you can create a seamless look throughout the entire space.

This adds a sense of cohesion and sophistication to your kitchen, making it feel more put-together and inviting. With coordinated kitchen decor, you can achieve a polished and cohesive look that will impress both family members and guests alike.

Modern gray kitchen island features dark gray flat front cabinets paired with white quartz countertops and a glossy gray linear tile backsplash

Cons of Adding a Kitchen Island

And let’s continue with some of the drawbacks of adding a kitchen island to your new space.

Coordinated kitchen decor

Adding a kitchen island may not be suitable for small kitchens. The addition of an island can take up valuable floor space, making it more difficult to move around and work efficiently in the kitchen.

In cramped quarters, the island may become an obstacle rather than a functional addition. It’s important to carefully consider the size and layout of your kitchen before deciding whether or not to add an island.

Higher cost

One of the cons is the higher cost associated with installing a kitchen island.

This additional feature requires not only materials but also professional labor for installation. Depending on your desired design and customization options, you may need to set aside a significant budget for this upgrade.

It’s important to weigh the benefits against this higher expense and ensure that it aligns with your overall budgetary considerations.

Furthermore, when considering the higher cost, it’s crucial to evaluate whether adding a kitchen island will provide sufficient value in return. While an island can enhance functionality and aesthetics in larger kitchens or open-concept homes, its worth might not justify the expense in smaller spaces where less room is available for movement.

Beautiful Farm House Kitchen island Modern cream kitchen features dark gray flat front cabinets paired with white countertops wood floor


In conclusion, adding a kitchen island can be a great addition to your new space. It provides more countertop space and storage, potential for extra seating, and enhances the overall definition of your kitchen.

However, kitchen islands may not be suitable for small kitchens because of the space constraints they come with, and can be an expensive upgrade.

Ultimately, you’ll want to weight the pros and cons of kitchen islands to see for yourself whether this upgrade is worth it or not in your particular space.

At Mortise & Miter, most of our kitchen remodeling projects in Overland Park, KS, include a kitchen island simply because in most cases, the pros of this upgrade outweigh the cons. Homeowners love getting a kitchen island for their remodels, and we’re here to deliver!

If you’re ready to get a free quote for your kitchen remodeling project, give us a call at (913) 214-6211 or request a free quote from from this link. We’ll help you make the most of your new kitchen cabinets, custom or not!